After your parents’ death, the family home was supposed to be sold and the proceeds divided between the siblings. But one heir has changed their mind. They live in the property, refuse to sell and say they cannot afford to buy out the others. Must everyone else wait indefinitely?
An inherited house represents more than financial value. It also carries memories, emotional attachments and often very different expectations among family members.
One person wants to keep the property. Another needs money to buy a home of their own. A third has been paying the building’s running costs for years and expects those expenses to be settled.
However, a refusal to agree to a joint sale does not mean that the situation cannot be resolved. Any heir may apply to the court for the division of the estate. This possibility is provided for in Article 1037 § 1 of the Polish Civil Code.
Three siblings inherit their parents’ house. One refuses to sell
Consider the following situation.
The following story is a fictional example intended to explain the legal issue.
Anna, Piotr and Katarzyna inherit a house with a plot of land from their parents. Let us assume that each has a one-third share and that the property is the estate’s only asset.
Anna and Katarzyna want to sell. Piotr has lived in the house for several years and has no intention of moving out.
During family discussions, he repeats: “I won’t sign the sale agreement. If you want money, you will have to wait.”
However, he offers no specific proposal for buying out the others. Eventually, he stops responding to messages.
Anna and Katarzyna begin to wonder whether their shares have any practical value when they can neither use the house nor receive any money.
Resolving the situation requires several issues to be considered separately: confirming entitlement to the estate, choosing a method of division and addressing any financial claims between the siblings.
Confirmation of inheritance and division of the estate — what is the difference?
These are two separate stages in settling a deceased person’s affairs.
A court order confirming acquisition of an inheritance or a registered notarial certificate of inheritance confirms who inherits and the size of each heir’s share.
It does not, by itself, allocate individual assets to particular heirs.
The division of the estate determines who receives specific assets and what financial settlements are required. The distinction between acquiring an inheritance and dividing the estate is also explained in guidance from Poland’s National Revenue Information service.
Therefore, saying “we have already completed the inheritance proceedings” does not necessarily mean that ownership of the house has been finally settled. It is worth checking exactly what the document you received establishes.
Can the whole inherited house be sold without one heir’s consent?
An ordinary sale of the entire property by its co-owners generally requires everyone’s consent. Holding a majority of the shares does not allow the majority to dispose freely of the share belonging to someone who refuses to sign.
However, consent to a joint sale must be distinguished from the right to request division of the estate.
A division by agreement requires all heirs to reach an agreement. If it includes real property, the agreement must take the form of a notarial deed. If no agreement can be reached, the court may divide the estate at the request of one heir. These principles are also described by the Lublin-Zachód District Court in Lublin.
An heir who opposes the sale may therefore present their position and propose a different method of division. However, their objection alone does not give them the right to prevent the matter from being resolved indefinitely.
How can an inherited family home be divided?
Where an estate includes a property, three main solutions are considered:
- physically dividing the property;
- awarding it to one person with an obligation to pay the others for their shares;
- selling it through the court procedure and dividing the proceeds.
The court does not have to order a sale simply because one heir requests it. The feasibility of division and the circumstances of the case matter. The order in which these solutions are considered is explained by the [Supreme Court in decision II CSKP 1859/22](https://www.sn.pl/sites/orzecznictwo/Orzeczenia3/II%20CSKP%201859-22.pdf).
Dividing the property
In suitable circumstances, it may be possible to subdivide the land or create separate ownership of self-contained residential units.
However, it is not enough to agree that “one person takes the ground floor and another takes the first floor”. A legal and technical assessment is needed, including access arrangements, the building’s layout, utilities and compliance with applicable regulations.
Under Article 211 of the Civil Code, division must not conflict with the law or result in a substantial alteration of the property or a significant reduction in its value.
Awarding the house to one heir
If physical division is not an appropriate solution, the house may be awarded to one person who must pay the other heirs for their shares.
It is then worth answering some specific questions:
- Who genuinely wants to take ownership of the property?
- How will its value be established?
- Where will the money for the payments come from?
- When will the other heirs receive their money?
- Will security for payment be needed?
Simply saying “I want to keep the house” does not resolve the financial problem.
Selling the property and dividing the proceeds
If an appropriate physical division is not possible and the property cannot be awarded to one person on suitable terms, it may be sold under the rules of civil procedure.
A court-ordered sale is different from jointly putting the house on the open market. Before the dispute escalates, it is therefore worth comparing the potential costs, timescales and consequences of the available solutions. The basic methods of division are set out in Articles 211–212 of the Polish Civil Code.
A sibling wants to keep the house but cannot afford to buy out the others. What happens next?
Not having the full amount immediately available does not necessarily make taking ownership impossible. However, there must be a realistic payment plan.
In court proceedings, payments to the other heirs may be divided into instalments. Under Article 212 § 3 of the Civil Code, the payment schedule cannot extend beyond ten years in total. The court also determines the timing and method of payment, interest and, where necessary, security. This possibility is discussed by the [Supreme Court in case II CSK 203/17](https://www.sn.pl/sites/orzecznictwo/Orzeczenia3/II%20CSK%20203-17-1.pdf).
However, this is not an automatic entitlement to a ten-year loan funded by the other siblings.
A practical proposal should specify amounts, dates and the source of funding. A promise to “pay you when I can” leaves the essential problem unresolved.
How is the house valued for the division of an estate?
Family disputes often begin with disagreement over the valuation.
The person who wants to take the house points to the renovation work it needs. The others compare it with the most expensive properties advertised nearby.
In a court division of an estate, the general approach is to consider the estate’s condition at the time the inheritance opened, meaning the date of the deceased’s death, while applying prices current at the time of division. This does not mean simply using the house’s historic price. The principle is explained by the [Supreme Court in decision IV CSK 177/14](https://www.sn.pl/sites/orzecznictwo/Orzeczenia3/IV%20CSK%20177-14-1.pdf).
If renovation work was carried out after the parent’s death, the valuation of the estate must be distinguished from the settlement of subsequent expenditure.
When preparing for discussions, it is therefore useful to gather not only current property listings but also evidence of the house’s condition and the work undertaken.
One heir lives in the house. Must they pay the others?
The fact that one heir lives in the property does not automatically mean that they must pay rent to their siblings.
Relevant issues include whether the others can also use the house, what arrangements were agreed and whether anyone has unlawfully excluded them from joint possession.
A situation in which the family agreed on a particular way of using the house differs from one in which a person changed the locks and refused everyone else access.
In its resolution of 19 March 2013, III CZP 88/12, the Supreme Court confirmed that remuneration may be claimed from a co-owner who uses common property in breach of Article 206 of the Civil Code in a manner excluding the others from joint possession. However, the requirements for such a claim must be assessed. Read the Supreme Court’s resolution.
It is worth keeping messages about access to the house, requests for keys and the responses received.
Renovations, taxes and bills — how should you prepare a financial settlement?
“I replaced the roof, so the house should belong to me” and “I don’t live there, so none of this concerns me” are positions that cannot replace an assessment of individual expenses.
When preparing a statement of costs, it is useful to list separately:
- work necessary to protect the building from damage;
- improvements and upgrades;
- taxes, insurance and other maintenance costs;
- charges linked to personal consumption;
- income, for example from renting out the property.
For each item, record the date, amount, proof of payment and what the expense covered.
In estate division proceedings, the court also determines certain mutual claims between heirs relating to possession of estate assets, benefits and income received, expenditure on the estate and estate debts paid. Raising these claims at the appropriate time is particularly important because of Articles 686 and 688, read together with Article 618 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Polish Code of Civil Procedure.
It is not advisable to leave all financial settlements until after the estate has been divided.
Can you sell your share in an inherited house?
Selling a share in a specific asset belonging to an undivided estate requires caution.
Under Article 1036 of the Civil Code, an heir may dispose of such a share with the consent of the other heirs. Without that consent, the disposal is ineffective to the extent that it would prejudice an heir’s rights under the provisions governing division of the estate.
It therefore cannot be assumed without qualification that selling an inherited share always provides a way around the dispute. The significance of this provision was analysed by the [Supreme Court in case I CSK 650/17](https://www.sn.pl/sites/orzecznictwo/Orzeczenia3/I%20CSK%20650-17-1.pdf).
Selling a share in the house must also be distinguished from transferring a share in the estate as a whole. Before signing an agreement, establish exactly what is being transferred and what the consequences will be.
Division of an estate and a reserved share — are they the same thing?
No. Division of an estate concerns allocating assets belonging to the estate among the people entitled to inherit. A reserved share, known in Polish law as zachowek, is a separate mechanism protecting certain close relatives of the deceased.
If the parents transferred the house to one child during their lifetime, dividing that house between the siblings may not be the appropriate starting point. The nature and effects of the earlier transaction must first be examined.
You can read more in our related article: Parents transferred an apartment to one child. Can the other child claim a reserved share?.
How much does a court division of an estate cost?
The application fees are:
- PLN 500 — for an application to divide an estate;
- PLN 300 — where the application includes an agreed proposal for division;
- PLN 1,000 — for division of an estate combined with termination of co-ownership;
- PLN 600 — where that combined application includes an agreed proposal.
These fees are set out in Article 51 of the Act on Court Costs in Civil Cases.
The application fee does not cover every possible expense. Additional costs may include expert opinions and legal assistance. How those costs are allocated depends on the course of the proceedings.
What documents should you prepare?
Before a consultation, it is useful to gather:
- Court orders confirming acquisition of the inheritance or notarial certificates of inheritance.
- The land and mortgage register number and documents concerning ownership of the property.
- Any wills that were made.
- A list of the estate’s other assets.
- Invoices, bank transfers and a statement of expenses.
- Information about use of the house and any rental arrangements.
- Correspondence about selling the property, buying out shares or access to the house.
- Your own proposal for resolving the dispute.
Where inheritance occurred successively after both parents, it may be important to trace both estates.
You do not need to wait until you have a perfect set of documents. A useful first step is to identify what is missing and where it can be obtained.
Frequently asked questions about an inherited family home and division of an estate
Can one heir prevent the matter from being resolved indefinitely?
A lack of consent may prevent a voluntary agreement, but it does not stop another heir from applying to the court for division of the estate.
Can a majority of the siblings vote to sell the entire house?
Holding a majority of the shares does not, by itself, replace the consent required for an ordinary sale of the entire property. Court division of the estate provides a separate route to resolving the situation.
Will the person living in the house automatically receive it?
Living in the property does not determine the outcome of the division. The available methods of division and the terms of any payments to the other heirs must be assessed.
Can payments to the other siblings be made in instalments?
Yes. The court may allow instalments under Article 212 § 3 of the Civil Code. This does not happen automatically.
Does paying for renovation entitle someone to a larger inheritance share?
Paying renovation costs does not, in itself, change the inheritance shares. However, it may need to be assessed as a basis for financial claims.
Do you need to know the exact value of the house before starting proceedings?
It is useful to prepare a reasoned proposed valuation and supporting documents. A valuation dispute may require an expert opinion.
Legal assistance with the division of an estate
A dispute over an inherited house rarely concerns only signing a sale agreement. It often also involves financial settlements, use of the building and the history of family assets.
Before starting proceedings, it is worth identifying the objective: taking ownership of the house, receiving payment for a share, dividing the property or ending joint ownership through a sale.
Angelika Mazur-Kubowicz’s Law Firm provides assistance with inheritance and property matters in Kraków, Proszowice and Mszana Dolna.
Assistance may include analysing documents, preparing a settlement proposal, assessing mutual financial claims and providing representation in court proceedings.
If you have inherited a house jointly with other people and cannot agree on its future, find out about the firm’s legal assistance in civil and inheritance matters.
Legal position as at 19 November 2026.
This article is for information purposes. Choosing a method of estate division and assessing financial claims requires an individual analysis of the documents and the circumstances of the case.

